Cesar Peres Dulac Müller logo

CPDMA BLOG

Category:
Date: April 14, 2022
Posted by: CPDMA team

Musical parodies do not need to mention the author of the original work, decides STJ

Musician and vocalist singing to illustrate the matter related to the STJ on musical parodies.

a few days ago the STJ published the result of a judgment promoted by the Court, which discussed the need to mention the author of the original work when making and disseminating a parody, in the light of copyright. 

The Superior Court of Justice granted the Special Appeal filed by Rádio e Televisão Bandeirantes (BAND), overturning the judgment of the São Paulo Court of Justice that had sentenced the broadcaster to pay R$ 10 thousand, as moral damages, to the author of music that had a parody of his work aired on the broadcaster's program, without credit being attributed to him as the author of the original work.

The author of the work maintained before the Supreme Court the claim for damages in the allegation of plagiarism of his music, which was not accepted. The understanding of the STJ, unanimously, was in the sense that the broadcasting of parody by the broadcaster does not infringe the copyright of the original creator, since the parody must be considered as an unpublished artistic work, a new intellectual creation that results from the transformation of a work previous. Therefore, the copyright on the parody would belong to its own creator, with no mention of the author of the inspiring work, not even alleging plagiarism.

Parody is a kind of reformulation of the original work, using comic terms or puns. The “new” music is made in a funny or educational tone and, as stated in art. 47 of the Copyright Law (Law No. 9.610/98), are free, as long as it is not a mere reproduction of the original work and does not imply discredit, and there is no need for prior authorization from the author. Typically, parodies use a familiar tune assigned to a new lyric.

The parody cannot, however, be confused with the music version. The broadcasting of a music version, without prior authorization, finds an obstacle in art. 46, item I, item “a”, of the Copyright Law. In the version, few changes are made to the music, taking advantage of a good part of the original work and, therefore, it is necessary to obtain prior and express authorization from the author of the musical work.

Intellectual Property - CPDMA

Return

recent posts

Extinção de sociedade limitada e a responsabilidade dos sócios

O processo de extinção de uma sociedade limitada passa por três etapas, sendo a primeira delas a Dissolução, seguida da Liquidação e por fim, a Extinção. A fase de Dissolução, podendo ser parcial ou total (para o fim de extinção, ocorre a dissolução total), pode-se dizer que é o momento em que os sócios manifestam […]

Read more
CARF Decide que demora na integralização do AFAC não descaracteriza operação e afasta incidência de IOF

A Terceira Turma da Câmara Superior de Recursos Fiscais (CARF), por voto de qualidade, entendeu que a demora na integralização do capital social nas operações de Adiantamento para Futuro de Aumento de Capital – AFAC não caracteriza a operação como mútuo e, com isso, afasta a incidência de IOF. O AFAC é uma operação que […]

Read more
Philco é processada por suposta imitação de trade dress de batedeiras

A multinacional Whirlpool, dona da KitchenAid e diversas outras marcas famosas no segmento de eletrodomésticos como Brastemp e a Consul, está processando a Philco por concorrência desleal e supostos ilícitos contra propriedade industrial da linha de batedeiras “Artisan” da KitchenAid. A ação tramita na 2ª Vara Empresarial e de Conflitos de Arbitragem de São Paulo, […]

Read more
The distribution of profits by companies undergoing judicial reorganization

Não são raras as vezes que podemos observar empresas cujos sócios possuem um baixo pró-labore e têm a complementação de seus rendimentos por meio de antecipação dos dividendos. A prática, [1] contudo, não se mostrava alinhada com os preceitos da recuperação judicial e o estado de insolvência das devedoras, uma vez que os sócios estariam retirando os […]

Read more
The possibility of attachment of the guarantor's family property

Recently, the Federal Supreme Court (STF) judged an Extraordinary Appeal, submitted to the rite of general repercussion, where by a majority of votes it understood to allow commercial property lessors to pledge the guarantor's family property to guarantee the receipt of rents not paid by the lessee. In his vote, the rapporteur, Minister Alexandre de Moraes, asserted […]

Read more
Musical parodies do not need to mention the author of the original work, decides STJ

A few days ago, the STJ released the result of a judgment promoted by the Court, which discussed the need to mention the author of the original work when making and disseminating a parody, in the light of copyright. The Superior Court of Justice granted the Special Appeal filed by Rádio e Televisão […]

Read more
crossmenuchevron-down
en_USEnglish
linkedin Facebook pinterest youtube lol twitter Instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter Instagram