Cesar Peres Dulac Müller logo

CPDMA BLOG

Category:
Date: July 8, 2019
Posted by: CPDMA Team

Spontaneous denunciation removes application of late payment fine, decides Carf

Late payment fines can be waived when there is a spontaneous report before the inspection begins. This is how the 1st Ordinary Panel of the 3rd Chamber of the 3rd Judgment Section of the Administrative Council of Tax Appeals established, following the understanding of the Superior Court of Justice. The judgment was published on 6/24.

Fines for late payment are waived for spontaneous reporting, defines Carf.

The understanding of the rapporteur, counselor Salvador Cândido Brandão Junior, prevailed. According to him, it is already a consolidated understanding in the STJ, including under the rite of repetitive, that the spontaneous complaint also removes the late payment fine.

"Spontaneous denunciation is configured in the event that the taxpayer, after making the partial declaration of the tax debt accompanied by the respective full payment, rectifies it before any procedure by the Tax Administration, notifying the existence of a greater difference, whose discharge takes place concurrently", he explains.

For the counselor, before the inspection start time, according to article 196 of the CTN, the taxpayer can spontaneously declare a tax amount due and not declared at the time provided for in legislation, constituting this tax credit with the monitoring of the tax amount and interest late payment, but exempt from penalties.

"If the taxpayer only collects in arrears an amount of tax already declared and constituted, this taxpayer will not enjoy the benefit of spontaneous denunciation, as there is no denunciation, only an untimely payment. This is also the understanding of the STJ", he says.

According to the counselor, there is no controversy that the case is a case of spontaneous denunciation. "The Tax Authorities' divergence lies solely in the argument that the spontaneous complaint does not exclude the late payment fine, since the late payment fine would not have a punitive nature. However, such an understanding does not deserve to prevail. late payment fines and ex officio fines, both having a punitive nature", he explains.

Case

In this case, the collegiate analyzed a tax assessment notice to establish a tax credit arising from late payment of IOF, however, without the payment of the late payment fine.

For inspection purposes, the spontaneous reporting institute provided for in article 138 of the CTN excludes only the payment of the punitive fine, but not the late payment fine. Thus, according to the Tax Authorities, when making the payment without computing the late payment fine, the taxpayer did not pay the IOF in full, which led to the assessment.

Source: Gabriela Coelho via Conjur.

Return

Recent posts

The STJ decides that stock options (option to purchase shares or quotas) cannot be seized.

On November 5th, the 3rd Panel of the Superior Court of Justice ruled, through the judgment of REsp 1841466[1], under the rapporteurship of Minister Ricardo Villas Bôas Cueva, on the impossibility of seizing stock options. The case focused on the possibility of a third party exercising the right to purchase shares in […]

Read more
Governance in family businesses: essential structures and instruments

Corporate governance in family businesses has been gaining increasing relevance in the Brazilian business landscape, where approximately 90% of companies are family-controlled. The lack of adequate planning for business succession and the difficulty in maintaining harmony in family relationships often lead to the company’s failure […]

Read more
Resolution No. 586/2024 of the CNJ and the Future of Agreements in Labor Justice

On 09/30/2024, the National Council of Justice (CNJ) unanimously approved Resolution No. 586 through Normative Act 0005870-16.2024.2.00.0000, which regulates the agreement between employee and employer in the termination of the employment contract, through approval by the Labor Justice system, with full settlement of the contract. In other words, […]

Read more
The Legitimacy of Associations and Foundations to Request Judicial Reorganization and the New Stance of the STJ.

At the beginning of October, the 3rd Panel of the STJ, by majority vote, issued a decision in four special appeals (REsp 2.026.250, REsp 2.036.410, REsp 2.038.048, and REsp 2.155.284), ruling against the active legitimacy of nonprofit foundations to request Judicial Reorganization. This unprecedented decision appears, at first glance, […]

Read more
Government of RS Establishes Recovery Program II: Installment Plan for Companies Under Bankruptcy Protection

The Government of the State of Rio Grande do Sul has instituted the Recovery Program II through Decree No. 57,884 of October 22, 2024, with the objective of allowing the installment of tax and non-tax debts for entrepreneurs or business entities under bankruptcy protection, including taxpayers whose bankruptcy […]

Read more
Renegotiation of BRL 60 Billion in Debt for Companies Under Bankruptcy Protection Regularized by PGFN

With information from Valor Econômico newspaper. Original article link: http://glo.bo/3NOicuU Since 2020, the Office of the Attorney General of the National Treasury (PGFN) has been advancing negotiations to regularize debts of companies under bankruptcy protection, resulting in the renegotiation of approximately BRL 60 billion. The number of regularized companies has tripled, reaching 30% of cases, thanks to a more collaborative approach from the […]

Read more
crossmenuchevron-down
en_USEnglish
linkedin Facebook pinterest youtube lol twitter Instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter Instagram