Cesar Peres Dulac Müller logo

CPDMA BLOG

Category:
Date: July 18, 2022
Posted by: CPDMA Team

STF decides that collective rule that restricts labor rights is constitutional

Illustrative image of industry workers to relate the decision of the STF, labor law and collective rule.

STF decides that collective rule that restricts labor law is constitutional. The Court observed, however, that the reduction of rights by Collective Agreements or Conventions must respect the guarantees constitutionally guaranteed to workers.

The Federal Supreme Court decided that Collective Bargaining Agreements or Agreements that limit or suppress labor rights are valid, provided that a minimum civilizing level is ensured to the worker. By majority vote, the collegiate granted the Extraordinary Appeal with Agravo (ARE) 1121633, with recognized general repercussion (Theme 1.046).

In the specific case, the decision handed down by the Superior Labor Court was questioned, which had ruled out the application of a collective rule that provided for the provision, by the employing company, of transportation for employees to travel to work and the suppression of payment for travel time. The reason for the decision was the fact that the company is located in a place of difficult access and that the public transport schedule is incompatible with the working day.

In the appeal, the employing company argued that, by denying validity to the clause, the TST would have exceeded the constitutional principle of the prevalence of collective bargaining.

In the trial, the vote of Justice Gilmar Mendes (rapporteur) prevailed in favor of the appeal. He stated that the jurisprudence of the STF recognizes the validity of a collective labor agreement or convention that provides for the reduction of labor rights.

The minister considered, however, that this suppression or reduction must, in any case, respect the unavailable rights, guaranteed constitutionally.

As a rule, the clauses cannot violate a minimum civilizing level, composed, in general terms, by the constitutional norms, by the norms of international treaties and conventions incorporated into Brazilian law and by the norms that, even infra-constitutional, ensure minimum guarantees of citizenship to workers.

about the hours on the road, the subject of the case under debate, the minister stated that, according to the jurisprudence of the STF, the issue is directly linked to salary and working hours, themes in relation to which the Constitution authorizes the elaboration of collective labor norms (item XIII and XIV of article 7 of the Federal Constitution).

He was accompanied by ministers André Mendonça, Nunes Marques, Alexandre de Moraes, Luís Roberto Barroso and Dias Toffoli and by minister Cármen Lúcia. Minister Edson Fachin and Minister Rosa Weber were defeated, who voted for the dismissal of the appeal. In Fachin's assessment, considering that the discussion of the case involves the right to overtime (on the road), provided for in article 7, items XIII and XVI, of the Constitution, it is inadmissible for collective bargaining to override the will of the constituent legislator.

Thus, the established thesis was as follows: “Collective agreements and conventions are constitutional which, when considering the negotiated sectoral adequacy, agree on limitations or departures from labor rights, regardless of the specified explanation of compensatory advantages, provided that absolutely unavailable rights are respected”. (1)

By: Douglas Moraes de Freitas

CPDMA Team - Labor

(1) Portal of the Federal Supreme Court

Return

Recent posts

Corporate name: get to know this asset class

Continuing with our series of posts explaining the differences between the classes of intellectual assets, today we'll look at the BUSINESS NAME. Although trademarks - the nature of which has already been described in the previous post - can sometimes be confused with business names, they are distinct legal institutes. The business name identifies the company by [...]

Read more
PERSE: legislative changes in the emergency program to revive the events sector

Law No. 14,859/2024: amendment of the Perse rules for the period 2024 to 2026. The Emergency Program for the Resumption of the Events Sector - Perse was created in 2021 with a view to helping companies linked to the events sector - the activity most affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, by reducing [...]

Read more
The extent of insurance cover in floods

The rains that have hit Rio Grande do Sul in recent weeks have destroyed farms, properties and vehicles. Even if they have insurance, car or property owners should check the coverage of their policies to see if they can get compensation. Basic insurance for cars and properties does not usually cover floods. Insurance against electrical breakdown, [...]

Read more
The agreement to sell the most famous slimming drug of the moment

It was recently reported that the Brazilian company BIOMM has signed an agreement with the pharmaceutical industry BIOCON to distribute in Brazil a drug similar to Ozempic, indicated for the treatment of diabetes, but used mainly to treat obesity. However, this will only be possible because the patent holder of the drug has certainly authorized, through a [...]

Read more
Get to know the “brand” asset class

Continuing with our series of posts explaining the differences between the classes of intellectual assets, today we're going to talk about the TRADEMARK. A trademark is a sign used to distinguish and identify a product or service. It is registered with the National Institute of Industrial Property (INPI), guaranteeing the owner exclusive use in [...]

Read more
Intellectual property gives the author, inventor or holder of knowledge the power to protect their rights.

Intellectual property gives the author, inventor and/or owner of the protected knowledge the power to protect their rights, and can, for example, prohibit third parties from producing, using, selling or importing their invention, as well as preventing the reproduction or imitation of their trademark, in addition to guaranteeing exclusivity to the owner of the creation [1] (ARAÚJO; BARBOSA; QUEIROGA; ALVES, 2010). [...]

Read more
crossmenuchevron-down
en_USEnglish
linkedin Facebook pinterest youtube lol twitter Instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter Instagram