STJ decides that the legal personality of a civil association can be disregarded, but limits liability to the directors
The 3rd Panel of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) [1] dismissed a special appeal filed by the directors of a civil association, which had its legal personality disregarded in a case involving the improper use of a trademark.
The Court, in a ruling authored by Justice Marco Aurélio Belizze, held that it is possible to disregard the legal personality of a civil association, but limited liability to the personal assets of members with management powers or capable of influencing decision-making that constitutes abuse of the legal personality.
As a rule, the institute of disregarding legal personality is applicable when abuse of personality is proven through confusion of assets or misuse of purpose, i.e. when the assets of the partners are confused with those of the legal entity or when the legal entity is used to achieve purposes for which it was not created. In these cases, the autonomy of the legal entity is allowed to be removed and the assets and rights of the partners themselves are affected. This is known as the Major Theory of Disregarding Legal Personality, which is set out in article 187 of the Civil Code.
Although it is an institute commonly used to resolve disputes in Brazilian courts, its application is generally restricted to legal models of companies, mainly limited liability companies, with few studies and judgments on its applicability to associations, foundations and corporations.
Thus, by deciding on the matter and recognizing the applicability of the disregard of legal personality in the case of civil associations, the STJ is helping to broaden the understanding and improve the technique for its effective use, avoiding conflicting decisions in other instances.
In his opinion on the applicability of the disregard of legal personality in the case of civil associations, Justice Marco Aurélio Belizze was clear in differentiating the type of relationship that the partner and the associate have, respectively, with the company and the association, thus underpinning the difference in treatment between the disregard of legal personality in one case and the other.
In his vote, the Justice stated that when the legal personality of a company is disregarded, what is achieved is a corporate contract, which binds its members in terms of obligations - with a strong personal element. In the case of associations, on the other hand, there is a legal agreement between the association itself and its members (and not between the members themselves) - there is not the same obligatory link.
Thus, there is a difference between the position of command occupied by some members and mere membership of the association, and it is unreasonable to extend the patrimonial liability that results from the disregard of the legal personality to the personal assets of a large group of members who did not participate in the acts that led to the sanction being applied.
The following excerpt is taken from the vote, which summarizes and defines the decision:
"Thus, the disregard of the legal personality of a civil association is admissible, but the liability must be limited to the members with management power or capable of influencing the decision that constitutes the abuse of the legal personality."
The decision thus seeks to ensure reasonableness and limit its effects to the assets of those who effectively act and have decision-making power over the association's course. It is these associates, members of the association's management or administration, who effectively gave rise to the applicability of disregard - whether through confusion of assets or misuse of functions - who will be personally liable for the damage they cause.
Therefore, this judgment serves as a warning to administrators and managers of civil associations, since they are the ones most affected by the recognition and application of the institute to the association. It is up to managers to ensure faithful compliance with the requirements governing the institution's legal personality, avoiding any decision that could lead to confusion of assets or misuse of functions and, consequently, direct liability for any damage.
The commission of jurists appointed by Minister Luis Felipe Salomão drafted the bill to update and adapt the Civil Code, which is currently awaiting review by the Federal Senate. The main objective of the draft bill is to simplify the measures stipulated by the current law and align the Code with doctrinal and jurisprudential interpretations that have been […]
The decision handed down by the Federal Supreme Court (STF) in the judgment of General Repercussion Topic 725 and the Argument for Non-Compliance with Fundamental Precept (ADPF) 324, marks a crucial point in the definition of labor relations and their legal limits in Brazil. In a scenario where companies are increasingly looking for alternatives to [...]
In the age of technology, the start-up ecosystem has attracted many people in recent decades. This is mainly due to the rapid rise of the digital economy, which has led to many success stories of companies that today represent giant players in the market, regardless of the sector in which they operate. In this context of scalable entrepreneurial initiatives, startups have shown themselves to be a huge attraction [...]
Closing our series of posts on the Classes of Intellectual Property Assets, today we're going to look at the registration of COPYRIGHT. An author is the natural person who creates a literary, artistic or scientific work. Copyright protects such works and can be patrimonial (right to commercial exploitation of the work) or moral (claim of authorship, conservation [...]
On June 26, 2024, a new type of operation was published covering companies with a tax domicile in Rio Grande do Sul. This is yet another measure taken by the Federal Government to deal with the damage caused by the floods in Rio Grande do Sul. The new operation, called "SOS-RS Operation", was instituted by PGFN/MF Ordinance No. [...].
In our series of posts explaining the differences between the classes of intellectual assets, today we'll look at DOMAIN REGISTRATION. The protection of a website's electronic address (domain) is carried out at Registro.BR. In this case, the domain availability search is essential for registration. If a third party tries to register a [...]
This website uses cookies to improve your experience as you browse the website. Cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored in your browser as they are essential for the basic functionality of the website to function. We also use third-party cookies, which help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Cookies will be stored on your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt out of cookies. However, disabling some cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Functional cookies help in performing certain functionality such as sharing website content on social media platforms, collecting feedback and other third-party features.
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information about the metrics of the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertising cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant advertisements and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors to websites and collect information to deliver personalized advertisements.
Necessary cookies are those that are absolutely essential for the proper functioning of the website. These cookies guarantee basic functionality and security features of the website, anonymously.